Vol. II, No. 199 From Our Region to Yours
Culture

The Router That Grounded America Was Part of the Upgrade, Says Duffy, Who Would Like Billions More for the Upgrade

Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy says a router in El Dorado, Arkansas, installed during the switch from copper to fiber, set off the biggest halt to U.S. departures since 9/11. Our outdoors editor knows the type. It never stopped casting.

Airport departure boards with long columns of flights marked cancelled
Photo: OhanaUnitedTalk page / CC BY-SA 4.0 via Wikimedia Commons

SOMEWHERE ON THE LAKE — The thing that grounded every departing flight in the United States on Friday afternoon was not a storm, a hacker or a flock of geese. According to Transportation Secretary Sean Duffy, it was a router in El Dorado, Arkansas, and it was put there to make things better.

“We think it was the installation or the router that was the bad actor,” Duffy said Sunday in an interview with Fox News, CNBC reported. In a separate interview on ABC’s “This Week,” he said the router sat in El Dorado, in the southern part of the state. It and another router from Amarillo, Texas, have been sent to an L3Harris Technologies lab in Florida to be examined.

This reporter has spent his life around small towns where one bad piece of equipment can ruin a whole weekend. He has never known one to ruin a whole country’s.

The upgrade

The router was part of ongoing work, overseen by L3Harris, to move the air traffic control system off old copper wire and onto fiber optics, CNBC reported. Federal Aviation Administration chief Bryan Bedford called the job a “routine” upgrade. L3Harris says it has finished more than 70 percent of the switch.

Then the new router began flooding the other routers in the system with more than 1,000 connection attempts roughly every five seconds, Duffy said. That scrambled communications with airplanes and radar feeds to the centers that handle high-altitude traffic, and then to the ones closer to airports. Officials were not sure for about 45 minutes what was causing it, Bedford said. “We were unwilling to take any risk that this propagation could actually result in a center losing connectivity with aircraft,” he said.

So the FAA halted departing flights around 4 p.m. Eastern on Friday. The ground stop lasted more than four hours, the longest pause on departures in 25 years and only the second nationwide ground stop since Sept. 11, 2001, CNBC reported. More than 9,000 U.S. flights were canceled Friday, about a third of the day’s schedule, though some of that was weather. Roughly 6,500 more were canceled Saturday, and more than 2,000 on Sunday, according to FlightAware.

Bedford said there was “zero evidence” that anything “nefarious” was involved, or anything to do with artificial intelligence. It was just a router that would not stop talking.

A word about overcasting

Every lake has one. You find a quiet cove at first light, you make one good cast, and then a boat pulls up 40 yards off and a fellow starts throwing a lure every five seconds, right across your line, at every piece of structure in the water. He is not catching anything. Nobody else is catching anything either. By 9 a.m. the bass have left for Louisiana.

That is what happened in El Dorado, except the boat was a router and the cove was the airspace over the United States. One thousand casts every five seconds. This reporter has fished beside some determined men. He has never seen anybody work the water like that. Big Doris herself would have gone deep and stayed there until Tuesday.

And here is the part that matters. When a fellow ruins the cove like that, you do not row back to the marina and ask for a bigger boat for him. You take away his tackle box.

The request

Washington has gone the other way. On Friday, Duffy blamed the country’s outdated air traffic infrastructure and said Congress needs to approve more money to overhaul it, CNBC reported. He has since used the ground stop to press lawmakers for billions more to modernize the system.

To review the situation from the dock: the old copper system is too old. The new fiber system is being installed. The installation is what knocked the country out. The answer is more installation.

This reporter does not say the money is a bad idea. The equipment is old. The controllers are short-handed. Airline executives have complained about the cost of the resulting disruptions for years. But a man can want a new outboard motor and still ask why the new one he just bolted on sank the boat.

Duffy, to his credit, wants to know too. Investigators are working out whether the problem was “user error, installator error from L3 Harris, or did they install a faulty router,” according to remarks quoted by CNBC. L3Harris said it is “supporting the FAA in its investigation.” The router, for its part, has been shipped to Florida, which is where a great many things from Arkansas end up after a bad season.

Thanksgiving

The airlines are still catching up. Delta offered crews double pay to pick up trips, American offered flight attendants extra pay, and United offered extra pay to pilots and flight attendants, CNBC reported. All of them are trying to get planes and people back where they belong before the Thanksgiving rush.

If you are flying next week, this reporter offers the same advice he gives anybody headed to a crowded lake on a holiday weekend. Leave early. Pack a sandwich. And if you see one fellow throwing a thousand casts every five seconds, do not wait for Washington to fix it. Find another cove.

The raccoon under this reporter’s dock, who leads their annual series 11 to nothing, has been informed of the El Dorado router and appears to feel seen.