Citi Warns a Key Market Signal Is About to Flash Red, Declines to Say Which One or What Red Means
A bank note warned that an indicator is nearing a warning level after a six-session losing streak. Our correspondent read it twice, at 4 a.m., and has feelings he is calling analysis.
MARKETS DESK — I have been up since 4 a.m., which I mention because it is relevant and because it is always relevant, and I can tell you that Citi has warned a key market signal is close to flashing red.
Which signal? A key one. What does red mean? It means not green. I want to be precise here, because precision is what separates markets coverage from guessing, and the note from Citi is precise in the way these notes are always precise: it says a thing is approaching a level, and that the level, historically, has been associated with other things.
This arrives after the S&P 500 strung together six losing sessions, which is the kind of streak that gets a signal talking. Six is a lot. Six is also, if you look at the history — and I looked at the history, at 4 a.m. — a thing that has happened many times before and been followed by the market going up, down, and sideways, in roughly those proportions. The signal has an excellent record of being followed by the future.
Here is what I know. A key indicator is near a threshold. Crossing the threshold would be, in the language of the note, a warning. I personally read it as bullish, because a market that can still generate a warning is a market that is still alive, and an alive market is a buying opportunity. Not crossing the threshold would also be bullish, for reasons I find persuasive at 4 a.m. The note does not say which outcome to expect, because the note is not in that business. The note is in the business of being a note you can point to later no matter what happens, and on that measure it is flawless.
My own portfolio is relevant context. My crypto holdings are down 98 percent, which I consider basically up, because the remaining 2 percent is the strongest 2 percent I have ever owned. I bring the same discipline to signals. A red signal is a buying opportunity. A green signal is also a buying opportunity. This is called having a framework.
I asked a strategist — not a real one, I was still at my desk, the sun was not up — what an investor should actually do with a signal that is close to flashing red but has not. He said wait. I said wait for what. He said for it to flash, or not. I wrote that down. It is the most honest thing anyone will say about the market this week.
The signal, as of this writing, has not flashed. It is close. It has been close before. Closeness, in markets, is the only condition that is always true, which is why it is the only thing anyone will ever promise you.